Worst to Best
Quentin Tarantino Movies

October marked the 25th Anniversary of Reservoir Dogs, the first feature by Quentin Tarantino. To mark this anniversary, The Anorak Zone decided to take a look back over his entire work as director...


by
THE ANORAK
NOVEMBER
2017


Tarantino's films are available from Amazon, including The Tarantino Collection. To make it easier to find each title, the links are placed under each image - click on each film's picture to take you to the relevant page if you wish to buy them.

11 Sin City (2005)

An adaptation of some of Frank Miller's Sin City graphic novel stories, directed by Miller himself, with Robert Rodriguez. Rodriguez and Tarantino had collaborated before on a number of occasions, including Rogriguez directing Quentin in From Dusk Till Dawn. After Robert had scored Kill Bill Part II as a favour for a dollar, Quentin returned the favour by directing a small segment of Sin City, also for a dollar.
     Innovatively shot on a sound stage in black and white with colour elements, the picture perfectly captures the feel of a comic format, and became much imitated thereafter. However, the deliberately ripe dialogue, spoofing the likes of pulp magazines and film noir, may be less palatable to modern audiences. Tarantino directed a short sequence with Dwight (Clive Owen) driving Jackie Boy (Benicio Del Toro), as pictured above.
     Tarantino sharing a segment of a movie was not unique to this project: the animated sequence in Kill Bill Part I was directed by Kazuto Nakazawa, and the film-within-a-film of Inglourious Basterds was helmed, uncredited, by Eli Roth.

10 Kill Bill
Parts I and II
(2003/04)

Kill Bill is Tarantino at his most repellent and indulgent, a tribute to Grindhouse Cinema that eschews all sense of good taste. Split into two parts due to a near-four hour runtime, the film shows a pregnant woman beaten unconscious, raped while in a coma, and, in a manga sequence, an 11-year-old girl having sex. Technically excellent, the picture is of a high standard in terms of pure film making, and Tarantino should, it could be argued, be commended for showing that women also get affected by violence. Yet even though the basic premise was co-devised by Uma Thurman herself, there's more than a whiff of misogyny about the entire project, and perhaps the question should be not why Tarantino would make this film, but why anyone would want to see it.

9 Four Rooms (1995)

After the huge success of Pulp Fiction, Tarantino seemed to be everywhere, from chat shows to bit parts, and even his own starring role in Destiny Turns on the Radio. Four Rooms was an experimental project that saw Tarantino and four other directors plan to create a film set in a hotel, made up of their five separate scripts and linked together as a single movie. Richard Linklater (Slacker/Dazed and Confused) pulled out before production began, leaving the film to be made up of the works of Allison Anders (Gas, Food Lodging), Alexandre Rockwell (In The Soup), Robert Rodriguez (Desperado) and Tarantino himself.
     As a low budget indie it has a certain merit, though unfortunately for the movie it was carried into cinemas on Christmas Day with a sizeable promotional push, making back little more than the $4 million production costs. The film has perhaps aged better than expected, whereby it can now be viewed shorn of a hype that it could not possibly hope to accommodate.
     Generally the best-received segment is "The Misbehavers", by Rodriguez, though Tarantino's "The Man from Hollywood" is not without a vague charm. As with a lot of Quentin's work, it subverts narrative expectations, in this case recreating a bet based on an old episode of Alfred Hitchcock Presents: a man must flick on his cigarette lighter ten times, or lose a finger. Rather than building any suspense, it opts for a left-field resolution whereby the first strike of the lighter fails.
     Loosely linking all four stories is Tim Roth, giving a bizarre, deliberately mannered performance as an eccentric bellhop. Largely a homage to Jerry Lewis (whose 1960 vehicle The Bellhop is even referenced) it would be lost on most of the youthful target audience and so the performance can be distracting without due context. In discussing performances, it should be noted that Tarantino casts himself as the star of his own short, playing a spoilt, egomaniacal hotshot film director. Whatever qualms one might have about Tarantino's insistence on taking acting roles in movies, this is one he's able to pull off to a tee.


8 My Best Friend's
Birthday (1987)

Co-written with Craig Hamann, Tarantino's amateur film debut was shot on 16mm over the course of four years. There's a persistent rumour that the film was completed but around half was destroyed in a fire; other sources suggest that this is untrue, and that the 36 minutes or so of remaining footage was all that was ever shot. Possibly such stories are confused with Tarantino's first film, an uncompleted 1983 short Love Birds in Bondage which was destroyed in a fire, reputedly by its director.
     As this is a ranking of Tarantino's work as a director, then his efforts as an actor are not included, from an appearance in every one of his films (three of them voice only) down to roles in Little Nicky, From Dusk Till Dawn and more. Allen Garfield was training Tarantino as an actor during the production (and appears here as "Entertainment Magnate") and the work sees Quentin in the lead role as Clarence Pool. Whatever the merits, or lack thereof, in Quentin's professional acting engagements, this is an amateur production and so in context his enthusiasm carries off the part of motormouth Pool, a guy who just wants to buy his best friend the perfect present.
     Technically this is easily the weakest film in this ranking, and the film stock is poor. That, and the fact that it's an uncomplete movie means that it's one for fans only. Tarantino was largely a self-taught director and didn't believe in the film school route; all his first mistakes are on film, the learning experience captured. Yet while there's no serious evidence of his later gifts, it has a kind of charm and good-natured enthusiasm that keeps it above some of his films that revel in their own mean-spiritedness.

7 Grindhouse (2007)

Another collaboration with Robert Rodriguez, this film sees both men craft their own exploitation cinema homage movie. Fake trailers come before and between the "double feature", including Machete and Hobo With A Shotgun, which went on to be made as films in their own right.
     Unfortunately, both films were realised separately outside of America and Canada, and released separately on DVD. Devoid of any context, the purpose of the film isn't as clear, and even Tarantino himself is on record as slating his part of the film, "Death Proof", as the worst film he's made to date. The most notable difference between the original format and its solo outing is that the lapdance sequence doesn't appear in the original, instead having a joke "reel missing" caption card in its place. While such an indulgent project is far from either director at their best, it's perhaps an underrated work, which, had it been released as intended in all territories, would maybe be more regarded.
     This particular "worst to best" article has been worked on very slowly, and actually has a 20-month gestation period, far longer than any other article on this site. Consequently it was begun and almost completed long before 2017's mass of allegations against Harvey Weinstein, the Executive Producer of this film, and the Executive Producer of eight other movies in this list. Tarantino movies, even the ones that disguise themselves as "pro-feminist" movies, always had a form of "boy's own" mentality to them, very much shot through the Male Gaze. The use of mistreatment of women as a narrative tool has always been a troubling subtext of Tarantino's work, but since the relevations surrounding Death Proof's Executive Producer came to light, it's made the works even more controversial and difficult to watch.
     While it must be acknowledged that, at date of writing, the incidents are still, legally speaking, allegations, it has cast an unfortunate shadow on so much of Tarantino's work. It was tempting to completely avoid discussion of this topic, and not trivialise very serious issues by mixing them in with discussion about movies, but due to the ubiquituous nature of these stories, it became almost impossible not to reference them.

1 Next